Jnc: Move ST506 discussion to appropriate Talk: page

2024-01-05T03:14:12Z

Move ST506 discussion to appropriate Talk: page

← Older revision		Revision as of 03:14, 5 January 2024
Line 26:		Line 26:
	We also need to think about replacing the technically incorrect [[:Category:DEC ST506 MFM Disk Drives]] with [[:Category: DEC ST506 Disk Drives]]. [[User:Jnc\|Jnc]] ([[User talk:Jnc\|talk]]) 17:39, 29 December 2023 (CET)		We also need to think about replacing the technically incorrect [[:Category:DEC ST506 MFM Disk Drives]] with [[:Category: DEC ST506 Disk Drives]]. [[User:Jnc\|Jnc]] ([[User talk:Jnc\|talk]]) 17:39, 29 December 2023 (CET)

	: Done. [[User:Jnc\|Jnc]] ([[User talk:Jnc\|talk]]) 04:13, 5 January 2024 (CET)		: Done. [[User:Jnc\|Jnc]] ([[User talk:Jnc\|talk]]) 04:14, 5 January 2024 (CET)

Jnc: Move ST506 discussion to appropriate Talk: page

2024-01-05T03:14:06Z

Move ST506 discussion to appropriate Talk: page

New page

==Correct name==

I don't know what the RDxx disks use for a hardware interface; I will look once the SDI disks are dealt with. MFM, as in [[Modified Frequency Modulation]], refers to how the bits are encoded in the magnetic layer; so unless there is some other expansion of 'MFM', that is not the name of the hardware interface. [[User:Jnc|Jnc]] ([[User talk:Jnc|talk]]) 22:25, 30 August 2023 (CEST)

: I already made a class "DEC ST506 MFM Disk Drives" (Sorry, my memory is very weak) - I think ST506 is the name of the hardware interface of the RDxx disks. So "DEC ST506 MFM Disk Drives" could be the MSCP sub-class for the RDxx disks. [[User:Vaxorcist|Vaxorcist]] ([[User talk:Vaxorcist|talk]]) 11:51, 31 August 2023 (CEST)

I looked in all the RD/RQDX documentation there was for a name for the interface to RD-series disks, but could not find one. Something in [https://forum.vcfed.org/index.php?threads/rqdx1-and-rqdx2-woes.58527/ Mattis Lind's note] made me think that it's an industry standard of some sort: "Formatting the disk with a ST class MFM controller". This implies than an RD disk will talk to non-DEC controllers --> the interface to RD disks is an industry standard.

If we knew more about 'ST class MFM controllers', perhaps that would tell us? I put 'ST class MFM controller' into a search engine, and after some reading, it seems that there is something of a standard interface used with early Seagate drives. (Good discussion [https://forum.vcfed.org/index.php?threads/mfm-drives-in-at-machines.72535/ here] and especially [https://groups.google.com/g/comp.os.cpm/c/BmmvgA0QGkU here]. Effectively an informal predecessor to IDE, but serial instead of parallel.) One person commented "I don't believe there was ever a generic name given to the interface"; people apparently started calling them 'MFM drives'. (Example [http://www.pdp8online.com/mfm/mfm.shtml here].) That is a poor name, though, because there are lots of drives that use MFM.

A name along the lines you used above might work, '''but''' it would be absolutely critical to have a page here describing this drive interface 'standard' in some detail, which the category header could link to. [[User:Jnc|Jnc]] ([[User talk:Jnc|talk]]) 12:28, 31 August 2023 (CEST)

: The "ST" is "ST506" (sometimes "ST412"), see [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ST506/ST412#Interface_to_controller]. All DEC RDxx disks can be used on ordinary early PCs (86/286/386), and some ST506 disks manufactured for PCs can be formatted and used with MicroVAXen and RQDX1/2/3 controllers. I can write a page on the ST506 standard. [[User:Vaxorcist|Vaxorcist]] ([[User talk:Vaxorcist|talk]]) 14:56, 31 August 2023 (CEST)

:: I found this page: [https://www.redhill.net.au/d/1.php hard drive history - beginings: mfm drives of the 1980s] which is a good brief intro. Amusingly (to me), it says "Note: 'ST-412' is correct. You will often see 'ST412' written in error": but if you look at the [http://www.bitsavers.org/pdf/seagate/mfm/ST-506/ST506_Product_Manual_Jul83.pdf ST506 Product Manual] and the [http://www.bitsavers.org/pdf/seagate/mfm/ST-412/ST406_ST412_ST419_Product_Manual_Jan84.pdf ST412 Product Manual], Seagate ''themselves'' didn't ''usually'' write 'ST-xxx' (although I did see one instance of that). They generally used 'STxxx', for the ST506, and 'ST xxx', for the ST412.
:: So, I think some variant of 'ST506' would be the right name, although I'd prefer [[:Category: DEC ST506 Disk Drives]]. (The 'MFM' kind of irks me, not least because a later 'ST506 interface' drive actually used [[RLL]], not [[MFM]]! :-). And yes, it should be a sub-category of the MSCP category. (Note, though, that I have put the SDI/LESI/DSSI disk categories in other categories ''as well as'' in [[:Category:MSCP Disk Drives]], to make them easier to find - other people might not think to look in 'MSCP Drives' for them.)
:: Yes, a page called [[ST506 disk interface]] or something like that would be good to have; although it should mention up top, where other names for them are mentioned, that many places/people call them 'ST412' and 'MFM disks'. [[User:Jnc|Jnc]] ([[User talk:Jnc|talk]]) 15:57, 31 August 2023 (CEST)

:: [http://www.pdp8online.com/mfm/mfm_old.shtml This page] calls it the "ST506/ST412 interface", which also a good choice. [[User:Jnc|Jnc]] ([[User talk:Jnc|talk]]) 17:36, 31 August 2023 (CEST)

::: Just created the page [[ST506 disk interface]] before reading your last message. Feel free to rename or improve it! [[User:Vaxorcist|Vaxorcist]] ([[User talk:Vaxorcist|talk]]) 09:51, 1 September 2023 (CEST)

:::: Let me think about the name a bit, and look around to see if other people show any preference between 'ST506' and 'ST506/ST412'. (I personally don't have any preference.) Once that decision has been made, we should make a ''lot'' of redirects, though!
:::: I think I can improve the text, and will do so. [[User:Jnc|Jnc]] ([[User talk:Jnc|talk]]) 12:45, 1 September 2023 (CEST)

We also need to think about replacing the technically incorrect [[:Category:DEC ST506 MFM Disk Drives]] with [[:Category: DEC ST506 Disk Drives]]. [[User:Jnc|Jnc]] ([[User talk:Jnc|talk]]) 17:39, 29 December 2023 (CET)

: Done. [[User:Jnc|Jnc]] ([[User talk:Jnc|talk]]) 04:13, 5 January 2024 (CET)

Category talk:DEC ST506 Disk Drives - Revision history

Jnc: Move ST506 discussion to appropriate Talk: page

Jnc: Move ST506 discussion to appropriate Talk: page